Stop Negotiating Positions. Start Negotiating What Actually Matters.
Most executive negotiations don’t fail loudly.
They fail quietly - inside polite meetings, clean decks, and “aligned” leadership teams that somehow can’t execute.
At the SVP level, this isn’t a communication issue. It’s a systems issue.
The Trap Senior Leaders Fall Into
A position is what someone says they want:
-
- “We need this launched by Q3.”
- “This team needs more autonomy.”
- “We can’t slow down right now.”
- “That process is non-negotiable.”
Positions feel decisive. They sound strategic. They create motion.
They also create:
-
- Silo warfare
- False consensus
- Decision paralysis
- Quiet resistance
- Strategy that looks good and fails fast
Because positions compete. Systems don’t.
The Distinction That Changes Executive Conversations
Fred Kofman frames this cleanly:
Positions → Interests → Commitments
Most leaders never get past the first layer.
1. Positions (The Particular)
Surface demands. Functional asks. Defensible stances.
Necessary - but insufficient.
Positions force zero-sum thinking. Someone wins. Someone loses. The system absorbs the cost.
2. Interests (What’s Important)
The underlying drivers behind the position.
-
- Speed
- Predictability
- Risk
- Control
- Trust
- Scalability
- Reputation
This is where negotiation becomes possible - because interests can usually be satisfied more than one way.
3. Commitments (The Essential)
This is where real leadership lives.
-
- What kind of company are we building?
- What tradeoffs are we willing to make?
- What will we not optimize for?
Commitments shape behavior long after the meeting ends.
Why This Is a Systems Problem (Not a Soft Skill)
At senior levels, conflict isn’t about facts. It’s about competing optimization logics.
When leaders argue positions:
-
- They defend their function
- Protect their metrics
- Reinforce silos
- Optimize locally
When leaders surface interests:
-
- Constraints become visible
- Feedback loops appear
- Tradeoffs can be designed instead of fought over
When leaders clarify commitments:
-
- Decision velocity increases
- Accountability becomes structural
- Execution stops relying on heroics
In systems terms:
-
- Positions = behaviors
- Interests = incentives & feedback loops
- Commitments = the paradigm the system operates under
Most organizations try to fix paradigm problems with behavior changes. That never works.
The Silent Failure Mode Above $50M
Here’s the pattern I see repeatedly:
-
- Smart, capable SVPs
- Clear strategy
- Good intentions
- Reasonable meetings
- Slow execution
Everyone agrees on the vision. Everyone leaves aligned. Nothing actually changes.
What’s missing isn’t talent or effort. It’s vertical movement in conversation.
What Strong SVPs Do Differently
The best senior leaders don’t negotiate harder. They negotiate higher.
They ask:
-
- “What risk are you trying to manage?”
- “What breaks if we get this wrong?”
- “What are we optimizing for right now?”
- “What future are we protecting?”
- “What tradeoff are we implicitly making?”
These aren’t empathy questions. They’re architecture questions.
From Functional Debate to Enterprise Leadership
At the SVP level, your job is no longer to win arguments for your area.
Your job is to:
-
- Turn conflict into clarity
- Make tradeoffs explicit
- Expose system dynamics
- Decide what the enterprise is truly committed to
That requires moving conversations:
-
- From my position → to our constraints
- From your demand → to shared outcomes
- From short-term wins → to long-term coherence
This is the difference between a leadership team and a high-performing workgroup.
The Most Dangerous Meetings
The most dangerous meetings aren’t heated. They’re calm.
If you leave a meeting with:
-
- Agreement but no ownership
- Decisions, but no behavior change
- Alignment but no execution
You negotiated positions - not commitments.
The Question That Changes Everything
The most useful question a senior leader can ask:
“What is this system currently optimized to produce - and is that what we actually want?”
Answer that honestly, and most executive conflicts dissolve.
Because when leaders stop negotiating positions and start negotiating what actually matters, the organization finally has something it can execute against.
And execution - not alignment - is what the market rewards.

Holly Lewis is a U.S. Navy veteran and Performance Coach with a Bachelor’s in Computer Science, an MBA in Technology Management, and more than 30 years of executive experience, including with McKesson Corporation, a Fortune 100 company. Known as a corporate intrapreneur, she has launched three nationwide commercial software packages and led high-performing teams to deliver results under tight deadlines. Holly helps leaders accelerate execution while also protecting what often gets ignored in high-performance environments, which is executive health. With numerous advanced certifications, she provides practical strategies to prevent and recover from executive burnout while transforming how leaders operate. Outside of work, she supports The American Legion’s advocacy for veterans, enjoys time with family, vegetable gardening, and exploring historic West Virginia with her husband.

0 Comments